Welcome to Gem City Saloon & Eatery
**Our Story**
Nestled in the heart of Baraboo, Gem City Saloon & Eatery has become a cherished local favorite, renowned for its extraordinary burgers and delicious pizzas. Locals rave about the juicy Gem Burger and the crowd-pleasing pan pizzas, often topped generously with high-quality ingredients. With a lively atmosphere, the saloon offers a full bar and outdoor seating, making it perfect for groups and casual gatherings. From Wisconsin cheese curds to build-your-own burgers, every dish speaks to hearty comfort and culinary passion. Join us at 124 Ash St and experience why this eatery is truly a gem in the community!
Gem City Saloon & Eatery: Reviews & Ratings
Great food and service! Pizza is delicious! A small is plenty for 2-3 people. Trust me!
Get the pizza! Great thin crust with loads of toppings. I go here for lunch every time I'm in Baraboo.
Great pan pizza, locals spot. Had both carry out and sat at the bar. A typical dive Wisconsin bar.
Great pizza and atmosphere. We had the large deluxe pan pizza... it did not disappoint.
Well, we went on a trip to Baraboo and truly found a GEM! We went there the first day and I was starving. I ordered a build your own cheeseburger and tots. The burger was just so tasty and perfectly made that for the first time in history I actually CLEANED MY PLATE! Then we saw the couple next to us ordered this pizza with toppings piled a mile high. We asked them about it and they said they traveled "an hour" just to get it. It looked very filling; they barely ate two pieces each. We could see pizzas were selling like hotcakes, so we came back the next day for one. Oh man, this pizza is amazing! The hunks of sausage were so huge they looked like chicken wings on top of it. Now people were asking US what we ordered! Really tasty food all around and good service. I highly recommend this place.
Excellent, excellent pizza. Lots of toppings with great sausage and fresh veggies. We also had the fried green beans that were very tasty. Service was great and prices very reasonable. Will definitely be back!
Great pizza at a very reasonable price!! Serviced quickly. Plenty for the two of us to take home for later. Twenty dollars will go a long ways here. Nice atmosphere, only issue I could see is parking is difficult as it's limited. Other than that, almost perfect!!!
We ordered cheese curds to start. My son ordered the boneless Buffalo wings which he enjoyed. My husband, myself and other son ordered the small pan style Carnivore pizza. It was delicious and plenty of leftovers to bring home.
Went to Gem city pizza and ordered 2 twelve inch deluxe pizzas for a party of four. Huge pieces of sausage, thin crust and almost two inches tall! We were hungry but could not come close to finishing it. Very tasty.
Location
-
124 Ash St, Baraboo, WI 53913 Hotline: (608) 355-9100
Welcome to Gem City Saloon & Eatery, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Baraboo, Wisconsin. Located at 124 Ash St, this vibrant eatery specializes in burgers and is renowned for its leisurely atmosphere and a menu that will satisfy even the heartiest of appetites. With its full bar and outdoor seating options, it’s a perfect spot for groups to gather, enjoy good times, and indulge in mouthwatering dishes.
Step inside, and you are greeted by an inviting ambiance, underscored by a moderate noise level — the perfect blend of lively conversation and the sizzling sounds of the kitchen. Customer favorites, such as the Wisconsin Cheese Curds and Gem City Deluxe Nachos, immediately draw your attention, showcasing the establishment's commitment to great flavors right from the start.
- Appetizers: Don’t miss out on the beer-battered shrimp and the spicy breaded pickle fries — they are the perfect start to any meal.
- Salads: For those looking for something lighter, the Gem Salad provides a refreshing option.
- Burgers: Customize your experience with a Build Your Own Burger or try the famous Gem Burger that locals rave about.
- Pizzas: Speaking of rave reviews, their pizza is the talk of the town. Customers flock to this spot for the thin crust adorned with generous toppings, and the deluxe pan pizza, praised for its hearty portions, is an absolute must-try.
- Sandwiches: The Philly Cheese Steak and Prime Rib Sandwich are popular choices, showcasing the kitchen’s ability to deliver traditional favorites with a unique twist.
Patty Z., a recent visitor, described her experience after trying the Build Your Own Cheeseburger and being blown away by its quality. Her enthusiasm is echoed by many, who assert that the platters at Gem City often lead to clean plates and lingering smiles. It’s evident that this place is not just a restaurant; it's a gathering hub where creative culinary expressions meet Wisconsin hospitality.
With a welcoming atmosphere, a diverse menu that caters to all, and stellar service, Gem City Saloon & Eatery is indeed a destination worth experiencing. Whether you are a local or passing through, be sure to stop by, dive into their savory offerings, and understand why so many return for seconds.
For inquiries, you can reach them at (608) 355-9100. Don't forget to check out the outdoor seating and enjoy a meal under the Wisconsin sky.
